Over my 20 years piping so far, I've come across so many different opinions on reeds that looking back, if I had a penny for each one, I'd be a rich man I tell you. So I've found myself wondering recently - what is the low down on pipe reeds .....
What makes each reed different ? Why make 'hard' reeds , when you can play a medium or easy strength one ? Why put yourself through the agony of blowing a hard reed? Are you meant to play a hard reed ever ? Is it ok to lick or wet your reed and if so, in what conditions would this be ok to do ? Is it ok to shave your reed, or cut along the sides like some people do ?
The questions go on and on and on. Most people will reed those and have some kind of opinion on them, but I want the low down. I want to speak to a reed maker and have a long chat about these questions. When I get a reed from my pipe major, most of the time it's almost impossible to play at first - whether I give a bit of moisture or not. Often the band will get a batch of reeds that are slightly more open than others. As most experienced players will know, trying to play those is like trying to squeeze a noise out of a brick - it just won't happen. I also don't see the point of struggling for ages and ages with a reed, making practices just absolutely grueling for weeks. OR - is this what needs to happen and should happen ? I just don't know anymore.
I heard once that a lot of the top professional players and Grade 1 players pipe setups are with reeds that are very easy to play (ok, so perhaps that's a massive generalization, but still) ? Is this true ? For me, it makes sense to have a chanter that doesn't need you to be looking like you're trying to blow a hot water bottle up like a balloon. It makes sense as your body won't be straining, therefore letting your arms and fingers remain more relaxed - but then again.... there's just another opinion.
So bring on the reed makers. I need to contact one. It's a shame I couldn't spend the time chatting with Donald MacPhee last weekend, but time wasn't on my side unfortunately. Reeds reeds reeeds ...... arrghhhh!!
No comments:
Post a Comment